Amartya Sen Offers Alternative to GDP

By Gautam S. Kumar, Contributing Writer

Economic experts pondered whether a different and more accurate economic health measurement system than GDP would have prevented the current global financial crisis during a panel at the Center for European Studies last Friday.

Harvard economics and philosophy Professor Amartya Sen and Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris economics professor Jean-Paul Fitoussi discussed their research on alternative ways of measuring the success of a society as part of a panel discussion organized by Center for European Studies visiting scholar Éloi Laurent.

Sen and Fitoussi were both members of the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress, a 20-person committee called together by French President Nicholas Sarkozy at the beginning of 2008 to determine a better technique to gauge the economic health of a nation.

The two economists presented the commission’s belief that their criteria of looking at income and consumption, happiness, objective measures of freedom, and freedom for well-being would provide a more accurate examination than GDP.

While higher GDP numbers are generally perceived to mean a country is more economically successful, Fitoussi, who joined the discussion through a video conference call, said that socially harmful activities can also lead to an artificial increase in a country’s GDP. For example, he said an increase in road traffic would drive up oil consumption and lead to larger GDP numbers that “obviously misrepresents the social wellbeing.”

While Sen said that these criteria would better measure economic success than GDP, they are not a “substitute for detailed analysis of social and economic conditions.”

He added that the lack of better indicators was not a valid excuse for not predicting the economic crisis.

“This was all evident with existing statistics,” Sen said. “That excuse—that we didn’t have the proper indicators—isn’t sufficient.”

European studies Professor Peter A. Hall and sociology Professor Michèle Lamont joined Fitoussi and Sen in presenting their work on the role of “the collective imaginary”—a group of people who form a perceived community—on “successful societies,” as Hall said.

Laurent said that the discourse between Sen, Fitoussi, Hall, and Lamont was even more “intellectually energetic” than he had expected.

“This was one of the best conferences in the now five years I’ve attended Harvard events,” said Jan Zilinsky ’09, a former Crimson editorial editor.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.

unable to load

From Our Advertisers

Elite Career Prep Platforms for Harvard Students | 2024
Sponsored
Elite Career Prep Platforms for Harvard Students | 2024

Take a look through our top picks for career preparation sites. Each of these can help undergraduates and recent graduates navigate the job and internship search process.

Huckberry Holiday Guide
Sponsored
Huckberry Holiday Guide

Welcome to your one-stop gifting destination for men and women—it's like your neighborhood holiday shop, but way cooler.

Build Community at Harvard: Summer 2025 Proctor Opportunities
Sponsored
Build Community at Harvard: Summer 2025 Proctor Opportunities

Serve as a proctor for Harvard Summer School (HSS) students, either in the Secondary School Program (SSP), General Program (GP), or Pre-College Program.

Successful Law School Essays | 2024
Sponsored
Successful Law School Essays | 2024

With an increasingly competitive Law School admissions process, it's important to understand what makes an applicant stand out.

MR. MBA: The Most Challenging College Admissions Cycle?
Sponsored
MR. MBA: The Most Challenging College Admissions Cycle?

In this article, Val Misra, Mr. MBA, will analyze and breakdown the numerous and unprecedented challenges faced by students, domestic and international, applying during the 2023-2024 college admissions season.

Unlocking Quant Careers: How WallStreet Quants Bootcamp Prepares You for Competitive Internships
Sponsored
Unlocking Quant Careers: How WallStreet Quants Bootcamp Prepares You for Competitive Internships

If you’re aiming to land a quant internship or early-career role at a prestigious hedge fund or HFT firm, WallStreet Quants Bootcamp offers the mentorship, structure, and practical training needed to set yourself apart in an incredibly competitive market.